How You Stopped 86% of Fake Orders in WooCommerce – The Story Behind It

Running an online store is exciting. You wake up every day to see new orders coming in. But what happens when some of those orders turn out to be fake?

That’s exactly what happened to us.

We were thrilled to see orders coming in quickly, but soon realized something strange:

• The email addresses looked fake.
• The phone numbers didn’t make sense.
• Most orders were being placed at odd hours, from countries we didn’t even serve.

It wasn’t long before we started getting chargebacks—that’s when customers complain and take their money back. It was a mess.

So, we decided to take action. We made some changes, and in just a few months, we stopped 86% of fraudulent orders. This is our story, and it’s written to help you fix the same problem.

The Problem: A Wave of Fake Orders

One of our eCommerce clients approached us with a growing problem:

• Dozens of fake orders daily were draining their time and money.
• Chargebacks were piling up, costing them additional fees.
• Genuine customers experienced delays as fraud disrupted their operations.

The client’s biggest worry?

“If we don’t fix this, we’ll lose both money and trust.”

They tried manual checks but couldn’t keep up. It was clear they needed a smarter solution—and that’s where we came in.

Why Fraudulent Orders Hurt More Than Just the Bottom Line

Fake orders do more harm than we imagined. For WooCommerce store owners like us, they lead to:

• Chargebacks: Payment gateways don’t care who’s at fault. You lose money and pay extra fees.
• Resource Drain: Processing, packaging, and shipping fake orders wastes time and resources.
• Trust Issues: When fraud affects real customers, it damages your reputation.

If you’re running a WooCommerce store, you can’t afford to let fraud continue unchecked.

The “Aha!” Moment: Connecting the Dots

One order changed everything.

A high-value product was purchased late at night. Something didn’t feel right. The name was “Mike Brown,” the email was [email protected], and the shipping address pointed to a remote warehouse in another country.

We ran a quick check:

• The IP address didn’t match the shipping country.
• The credit card belonged to someone in Germany—while the product was shipping to an address in India.

It was clear: card-testing fraud.

Fraudsters were testing stolen credit cards by placing small, legitimate-looking orders. If the card worked, they would move on to bigger purchases.

That’s when we realized two things:

• Fraudsters follow patterns—you just need to spot them.
• A reactive approach wasn’t enough; we needed to be proactive.

The Real Impact: A Turning Point

The next two weeks were tough. Here’s what we were dealing with:

• 100+ fake orders a week.
• Chargeback fees are piling up.
• Real customers questioning delays caused by operational chaos.

At this point, our team huddled together: What were we missing?

That’s when we found the cracks:

• We had no order validation beyond basic payment approval.
• Our checkout process wasn’t filtering bots.
• We weren’t monitoring for suspicious patterns.

Fraud wasn’t just “happening”—we had left the door wide open.

How We Solved It: A Step-by-Step Approach

When we took on the challenge, we followed a simple yet effective plan to stop fraud in its tracks:

1. Installing Anti-Fraud Tools

We integrated WooCommerce Anti-Fraud and FraudLabs Pro plugins. These tools automatically flagged risky orders based on:

• Suspicious emails (e.g., free email providers like Gmail with random numbers).
• IP addresses from countries known for fraud.
• Mismatched billing and shipping details.

How it helped:

The client no longer needed to review every order manually. High-risk orders were flagged instantly, saving hours of time.

2. Adding CAPTCHA to Checkout

Most fraudulent orders start with bots—programs that place fake orders in bulk.

To stop this, we added Google reCAPTCHA to the checkout process.

The result:

• Bots were blocked immediately.
• Genuine customers could still place orders without any issues.

3. Enabling Payment Gateway Fraud Protection

We configured fraud detection filters provided by their payment gateway (Stripe and PayPal):

• Address Verification System (AVS): Checked if the billing address matched the credit card details.
• CVV Matching: Required the 3-digit code for every payment.
• Velocity Rules: Stopped multiple failed attempts from the same IP address.

Outcome:

Fraudsters testing stolen cards were instantly blocked.

4. Real-Time Monitoring of Orders

Using IP tracking and analytics, we monitored patterns for fraudulent activity:

• Orders from unfamiliar countries.
• Large quantities of small orders.
• Repeated attempts with different cards.

We set up automated rules to flag such orders for manual review or block them outright.

5.  Setting Custom Rules for High-Risk Orders

We helped the client create specific rules for their store:

• Orders over $500 were held for manual review.
• Orders from high-risk countries required email or phone verification.

This ensured that real customers could still order, but risky ones were double-checked.

The Results: Fraud Dropped by 86%

Within two months:

• Fraudulent orders dropped from 100+ to fewer than 15 a month.
• Chargebacks plummeted, saving us nearly $1,800 monthly.
• Order processing became smoother, freeing up our team to focus on real customers.

The best part? Our store’s reputation improved. Customers noticed faster order fulfillment, and we regained their trust.

“We realized that preventing fraud isn’t just about tools—it’s about vigilance.”

Lessons Learned: What You Can Take Away

Here’s what this experience taught us—and what you can apply to your WooCommerce store:

• Don’t Ignore the Red Flags: Suspicious details like mismatched addresses and unrealistic emails are often the first signs.
• Start Small, but Start Now: Tools like CAPTCHA, anti-fraud plugins, and IP monitoring are easy wins.
• Review and Adapt: Fraudsters evolve. Regularly review orders, patterns, and tools to stay ahead.

Final Thoughts: Don’t Let Fraud Steal Your Profits

Fraud might feel like an unstoppable force, but it isn’t. By recognizing patterns, using the right tools, and staying vigilant, you can stop it in its tracks—just like we did.

If you’re dealing with fraudulent orders right now, remember this: Small steps lead to big wins.

We stopped 86% of fraudulent orders. So can you.

Need Help Securing Your WooCommerce Store?

Ready to stop fraud and protect your revenue? Let’s build a secure WooCommerce store together.